What makes me the same person over time?
Reid criticized Locke's memory theory, noting it yields paradoxes such as the brave officer who forgets his boyhood flogging. He held that personal identity is simple and indivisible, grounded in a persisting subject.
Memory is evidence of who you are, not what makes you who you are; you are a single enduring subject, not a collection of linked memories.
Source: Essays on the Intellectual Powers of Man