W. D. Ross

Intuitionist pluralism · Modern · Scotland

Wikipedia

Sir William David Ross, known as David Ross but usually cited as W. D. Ross, was a Scottish Aristotelian philosopher, translator, WWI veteran, civil servant, and university administrator. His best-known work is The Right and the Good (1930), in which he developed a pluralist, deontological form of intuitionist ethics in response to G. E. Moore's consequentialist form of intuitionism. Ross also critically edited and translated a number of Aristotle's works, such as his 12-volume translation of Aristotle together with John Alexander Smith, and wrote on other Greek philosophy.

Summary from Wikipedia.

Saved takes

Is it ever right to break a promise?

Ross argues that fidelity is one of several prima facie duties, alongside beneficence and non-maleficence. When duties conflict, we must judge which is more stringent in the particular situation.

The duty to keep a promise is real but not absolute; a stronger duty, like preventing serious harm, can override it in a given case.

Source: The Right and the Good

What is duty?

Ross argues that we have several irreducible prima facie duties, such as fidelity, gratitude, justice and beneficence. When they conflict, we must judge which is most stringent in the situation without a fixed formula.

There are many distinct basic obligations, each binding on its face, and wisdom lies in weighing them when they collide.

Source: The Right and the Good