Ethics

Is it ever right to break a promise?

Most of these thinkers agree that promises carry real moral weight because they sustain trust and cooperation, and most allow rare exceptions for serious harm or changed circumstances. They split mainly over whether the duty is absolute (Kant), outcome-dependent (Bentham, Mill, Hume), balanced against other duties (Ross, Plato, Cicero, Aquinas), or a matter of personal responsibility and relational trust (Sartre, Arendt, Baier).

12 perspectivesClaude Sonnet 5.5Updated Oct 27, 2026A fresh run is rate limited and uses the same request limits as the rest of Perspective.

Answerability

No right answer

22 / 100

NoneContestedFactual

Common ground

Where they agree

  • Promise-keeping matters a great deal: nearly all of them tie it to…
  • Most of them treat the duty as strong but not unlimited, so…
  • Promises extracted by fear or deceit, or aimed at a wrongful end…
  • Breaking a promise carries a real cost to trust and expectation, which…

Fault lines

Where they differ

  • Kant holds that promise-keeping is a strict duty that does not depend on consequences. Bentham and, to a lesser degree, Mill let the balance of outcomes decide.
  • Plato, Cicero and Aquinas ground exceptions in justice, the common good and what is truly good. Hobbes grounds them in the lack of assurance that the other side will perform. Hume grounds them in social utility and Ross in conflicting prima facie duties.
  • Ross and Sartre both accept real moral conflict, but Ross thinks careful judgment can find the weightier duty, while Sartre says no rule or theory settles it and the chooser must simply own the choice.
  • Arendt and Baier locate the wrong in damage to relationships and the shared world, and Arendt adds forgiveness as the remedy. Kant and the utilitarians locate it in a violated rule or in aggregate welfare.
  • Hume and Hobbes treat promising as a human convention serving interest or peace, while Kant treats it as a requirement of reason, and Aquinas treats it as part of the virtue of justice.

The council

12 perspectives

Plato

c. 428–348 BCE · Greece

Greek philosophy

In the Republic, Socrates examines the idea that justice means keeping one's word and returning what one owes. He tests it with a case where returning a weapon to a deranged friend would cause harm.

Keeping a commitment is not right in itself when doing so would bring serious harm; justice must be guided by understanding of what is truly good, not mechanical rule-following.

Source: Republic

Cicero

Rome

Roman Stoicism

Cicero discusses conflicts between duties and argues that promises are not binding when keeping them would harm the person to whom they were made or when they were extracted by fear or deceit. He treats good faith as a foundation of justice yet subordinate to the common good.

A promise binds only within the limits of justice and benefit; if circumstances change so that fulfilling it would do more harm than good, a person may rightly set it aside.

Source: De Officiis

Thomas Aquinas

1225–1274 · Italy

Scholasticism

Aquinas holds that fidelity to promises is a part of justice, yet obligations depend on the promise being for a possible and morally good end. Changed circumstances can excuse a person from performing what was promised.

One should keep promises ordinarily, but if conditions shift so that fulfilment would be wrong or truly harmful, not performing it does not count as vice.

Source: Summa Theologiae

Social contract theory

Hobbes makes keeping covenants the third law of nature and the root of justice. But covenants made under no assurance that the other side will perform do not bind, since reasonable fear of non-performance releases one.

Promises must generally be kept because without that there is no peace, but where the other party is likely to cheat, one is not bound to perform first.

Source: Leviathan

David Hume

1711–1776 · Scotland

Empiricism

Hume views promising as an artificial convention that arises because it serves mutual interest and cooperation. Its obligation derives from social utility, not from a mysterious act of will.

The duty to keep promises exists because the practice benefits society; so exceptions are appropriate only when they do not undermine the convention that makes trust possible.

Source: A Treatise of Human Nature

Immanuel Kant

1724–1804 · Prussia

Deontology

Kant uses the false promise as a central example of a maxim that cannot be universalized, since it would destroy the very practice of promising. He therefore treats promise-keeping as a strict duty not to be bent by convenience.

Making a promise one intends to break is irrational and wrong because it could not be a universal law; duty to keep one's word does not depend on how things turn out.

Source: Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals

Ask your own

0 / 300