Ethics

What is duty?

The thinkers agree that duty is a claim on us that goes beyond whim, and many of them tie it to roles, relationships or the needs of others. They disagree about where it comes from, whether it is universal or situational, whether it is judged by motive or outcome, and whether it is given to us or created by us.

12 perspectivesClaude Sonnet 5.5Updated Oct 27, 2026A fresh run is rate limited and uses the same request limits as the rest of Perspective.

Answerability

No right answer

20 / 100

NoneContestedFactual

Common ground

Where they agree

Fault lines

Where they differ

  • Source of duty: Kant locates it in pure practical reason, Confucius, Epictetus and the Gita in roles and station, Cicero in a rational and social nature, Mill in general happiness, Hobbes in covenant and sovereign authority, Levinas in the Other's face, Weil in human needs, and Sartre in free self-created choice.
  • Universal versus particular: Kant's imperative binds all rational beings alike, while Confucius, Epictetus and the Gita make duty depend on one's particular place and nature.
  • Motive versus consequence: Kant says moral worth lies in acting from duty regardless of outcome, whereas Mill judges duty by its contribution to happiness and Hobbes by its service to security. The Gita and Epictetus stress detachment from outcomes.
  • Single principle versus plurality: Kant and Mill derive duties from one supreme principle, while Ross holds that several irreducible duties must be weighed by judgment.
  • Given versus created: Sartre rejects duties as externally given and sees appeals to them as bad faith, whereas Kant, the Gita, Confucius and Levinas treat duty as binding independently of what one chooses.
  • Obedience: Hobbes grounds duty in obeying the sovereign, while Arendt warns that obedience presented as duty can replace moral thinking.
  • Freedom and responsibility: Levinas says responsibility precedes freedom, while Sartre makes responsibility an outcome of radical freedom.

The council

12 perspectives

Immanuel Kant

1724–1804 · Germany

German Idealism

Kant treats duty as the core of moral worth: an action is morally good only when done out of respect for the moral law, not from inclination or expected benefit. Duty is expressed through the categorical imperative, which binds all rational beings unconditionally.

To act dutifully is to do what reason demands of any rational agent, simply because it is right, regardless of what you desire or what you stand to gain.

Source: Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals

Confucius

551–479 BCE · China

Confucianism

For Confucius, duty arises from roles and relationships such as parent and child, ruler and subject, friend and friend. Fulfilling them with sincerity, ritual propriety and benevolence cultivates a moral person and a harmonious society.

Duty is the faithful living out of the obligations attached to your place in the web of human relationships, carried out with care and respect.

Source: Analects

Cicero

Rome

Roman Stoicism

Cicero adapts Stoic thought to Roman public life, arguing that duties follow from our nature as rational and social beings. He insists that what is honorable and what is useful never truly conflict.

Our duties come from our shared human nature and our bonds with others, and doing them is inseparable from living honorably.

Source: De Officiis

Epictetus

Greco-Roman world

Stoicism

Epictetus holds that duty follows from the roles we occupy, as citizen, child, sibling or parent, and that we should perform them well while accepting what lies beyond our control. Virtue lies in the quality of our choices within those roles.

Ask what your roles require of you and do that well, leaving outcomes to fate.

Source: Discourses

Hindu philosophy

The Gita presents dharma as the duty fitted to one's station and nature, taught to Arjuna on the battlefield. It urges acting without attachment to the fruits of action, as an offering.

Do the work that is rightfully yours with full commitment, while letting go of craving for its rewards.

Source: Bhagavad Gita

Utilitarianism

Mill grounds duty in the promotion of general happiness. Something is a duty when failing to do it would properly warrant punishment or social censure, because it undermines the common good.

A duty is an act whose neglect is rightly blamed, because society is better off when such acts are required of everyone.

Source: Utilitarianism

Ask your own

0 / 300