Thomas Nagel

Analytic philosophy · Contemporary · United States

Wikipedia

Thomas Nagel is an American postanalytic philosopher. He is a professor of philosophy, a professor of law, and University Professor of Philosophy and Law Emeritus at New York University. From 2001 to 2003, he was the Fiorello LaGuardia Professor of Law at the New York University School of Law. His main areas of philosophical interest are political philosophy, ethics, and philosophy of mind.

Summary from Wikipedia.

Saved takes

Could a machine be conscious?

Nagel argues that consciousness means there is something it is like to be a subject, and that objective physical descriptions seem unable to capture this. This makes it hard to know, from outside, whether any machine has such a point of view.

An organism is conscious if there is something it is like to be it, and third-person science struggles to tell us whether that holds for a machine.

Source: What Is It Like to Be a Bat?

Is life absurd?

Nagel holds that absurdity comes from the collision between our serious commitment to our lives and our ability to step back and see that this seriousness can be doubted. He thinks the right response is irony rather than heroism or despair.

We are absurd creatures because we can view our own earnest striving from an outside standpoint that makes it look arbitrary, and we should meet this with wry detachment.

Source: The View from Nowhere

Is reality independent of the mind?

Nagel defends a form of realism holding that reality extends beyond what any human mind can conceive. He argues that objective reality is independent of our perspective, even though our understanding of it is limited.

The world exceeds our minds; taking the objective standpoint means recognizing that reality includes aspects we may never be able to grasp.

Source: The View from Nowhere

What is consciousness?

Nagel argues that consciousness is the subjective character of experience, the fact that there is something it is like to be a creature. He holds that objective physical accounts currently leave this out.

An organism is conscious when there is a subjective point of view to be had, and that perspective resists capture by purely physical description.

Source: What Is It Like to Be a Bat? (essay)