Ethics

Is it ever right to lie?

The thinkers split between those who hold that lying is always wrong (Kant, Augustine, Aquinas, Gandhi) and those who permit it under pressing circumstances such as protecting others, serving the common good or political necessity (Constant, Mill, Bonhoeffer, Plato, Machiavelli). Bok seeks a middle course that requires strong, publicly defensible justification, Arendt stresses the political danger of organised lies, and Nietzsche challenges the very distinction between truth and falsehood.

12 perspectivesClaude Sonnet 5.5Updated Oct 27, 2026A fresh run is rate limited and uses the same request limits as the rest of Perspective.

Answerability

No right answer

20 / 100

NoneContestedFactual

Common ground

Where they agree

  • Almost all of them treat truthfulness as a weighty value; even those…
  • Kant, Augustine, Aquinas and Gandhi agree that deliberately asserting what one believes…
  • Kant, Augustine and Arendt share the view that lying damages trust and…
  • Aquinas, Bonhoeffer and Bok point toward alternatives to outright lying, such as…
  • Plato, Machiavelli and Arendt recognise that deception has long been an instrument…

Fault lines

Where they differ

  • Absolutists (Kant, Augustine, Aquinas, Gandhi) hold that no lie is ever right, while Constant, Mill, Bonhoeffer, Plato and Machiavelli allow some lies.
  • Kant rejects the murderer-at-the-door exception, whereas Constant argues that someone intending harm has no right to the truth.
  • Mill justifies lies by their consequences for general happiness, while Kant and Augustine ground the ban in duty or the purpose of speech regardless of outcomes.
  • Aquinas permits concealment but not falsehood, while Bonhoeffer holds that misleading an unjust interrogator can itself be faithful to truth.
  • Plato and Machiavelli accept deception by rulers as a political necessity or tool, while Gandhi rejects deception even as a political tactic and Arendt sees organised lying as gravely corrosive.
  • Bok offers a presumption against lying that can be overcome by a public test, a middle path between absolute prohibition and open permission.
  • Nietzsche questions the framing itself, seeing truth and lying as expressions of drives and power rather than a clear moral line.

The council

12 perspectives

Immanuel Kant

1724–1804 · Germany

Deontology

Kant held that lying violates the duty of truthfulness and treats others as mere means. He argued the prohibition is categorical, admitting no exception even for a murderer at the door.

A lie corrupts the very possibility of trust and rational communication, so no consequence, however sympathetic, can make it permissible.

Source: On a Supposed Right to Lie from Philanthropy

Augustine of Hippo

North Africa

Christian philosophy

Augustine argued that every lie is a sin because speech exists to convey what one thinks. He distinguished kinds of lies by gravity but refused to approve any as right.

Words are given so that minds can be disclosed to one another, so deliberately saying what you believe false misuses that gift, even for a good end.

Source: On Lying

Thomas Aquinas

1225–1274 · Italy

Scholasticism

Aquinas classed lies as officious, jocose, or malicious and held all to be sinful in kind, though differing in severity. He allowed concealing the truth or speaking evasively when justice or charity requires.

Asserting a falsehood is always wrong, yet one need not reveal everything; prudent silence or discretion can protect others without lying.

Source: Summa Theologiae

Plato

c. 428–348 BCE · Greece

Greek philosophy

Plato condemned the true lie in the soul but allowed rulers to use falsehood for the good of the city. His noble lie myth and talk of lying as medicine reveal a political exception.

Deceiving the soul about what is real is the worst falsehood, yet a guardian may use a useful fiction or medicinal untruth to secure civic harmony.

Source: Republic

Liberalism

Constant criticized the absolute duty of truth-telling, arguing that duties correlate with rights. He held that no one has a right to a truth that would harm others.

The obligation to tell the truth only holds toward those entitled to it, so someone seeking to do harm has no claim on an honest answer.

Source: Des réactions politiques

Utilitarianism

Mill judged actions by their tendency to promote happiness. He regarded truthfulness as extremely valuable for social trust but accepted rare exceptions where deception averts great harm.

Honesty usually serves the general good so strongly that lying is seldom justified, yet when a falsehood prevents serious harm, the principle of utility can permit it.

Source: Utilitarianism

Ask your own

0 / 300