Relationships · Ethics

Should I have kids?

The thinkers largely agree that having children is a weighty decision that should be made reflectively, and most allow that a good life is possible either way. They split on whether parenthood is a path to virtue and meaning (Confucius, Aristotle, Jonas), a risk to peace or a trap of nature (Epicurus, Schopenhauer), a moral problem (Benatar), or a free and unpredictable leap shaped by social pressure (Beauvoir, Paul, Ahmed).

12 perspectivesClaude Sonnet 5.5Updated Oct 27, 2026A fresh run is rate limited and uses the same request limits as the rest of Perspective.

Answerability

No right answer

12 / 100

NoneContestedFactual

Common ground

Where they agree

  • Having children is a serious decision that calls for reflection rather than…
  • A good life does not strictly require children: Aristotle, Augustine, Epicurus, Beauvoir…
  • Parenthood is bound up with responsibility and care, whether seen as a…
  • Beauvoir and Ahmed agree that social expectation can distort the decision and…
  • Aristotle and Hursthouse agree that practical wisdom and attention to one's own…

Fault lines

Where they differ

  • Confucius treats raising children and continuing the family line as central to becoming fully human, while Benatar holds that procreation is generally morally problematic.
  • Aristotle and Jonas see parenthood as an exercise and deepening of virtue, whereas Schopenhauer sees the urge to procreate as a trick of the will that serves the species at the individual's expense.
  • Epicurus judges the choice by its effect on tranquility and friendship, while Kant and Jonas stress duties that bind you once a child exists, regardless of comfort.
  • Augustine ranks celibacy above procreation as a higher calling, while Confucius ranks family continuation as among the highest duties.
  • Paul holds that the choice cannot be settled by weighing expected outcomes because the experience transforms who you are, while Benatar and Epicurus rely on a kind of accounting of harms, benefits or disturbance.
  • Beauvoir and Ahmed focus on freedom from social scripts, whereas Confucius sees obligations to family and ancestors as constitutive of a meaningful life rather than as constraints.

The council

12 perspectives

Aristotle

384–322 BCE · Greece

Aristotelian virtue ethics

Aristotle saw the household and family as a natural stage in human flourishing, a setting where friendship, virtue and shared life develop. Raising children is part of the larger life of a political animal, though it is not the only route to a good life.

A fulfilled life usually includes family bonds, because caring for offspring exercises virtues that solitary life cannot, but it must be pursued with practical wisdom about one's circumstances.

Source: Nicomachean Ethics

Confucius

551–479 BCE · China

Confucianism

In the Confucian tradition, family relationships are the root of moral cultivation. Filial piety and the continuation of the family line are central to a meaningful human life.

Becoming fully human happens through relationships of reciprocal duty, and raising the next generation is a core way of honoring those who came before and shaping those who follow.

Source: Analects

Epicurus

341–270 BCE · Greece

Epicureanism

Epicurus prized tranquility and friendship, and reportedly counseled the wise to be wary of the anxieties that family life and public affairs can bring. Reports of his view are mixed, and the question turns on what secures lasting peace of mind.

Choose whatever path leaves you least disturbed and most able to enjoy simple pleasures and friends; children are a risk to that calm for some people and a source of joy for others.

Source: Letter to Menoeceus

Augustine of Hippo

North Africa

Christian theology

Augustine regarded marriage and procreation as genuine goods, though he ranked consecrated celibacy higher. He treated children as a gift and a responsibility within a life ordered toward God.

Having children is a real good when received as a gift and raised with love, yet it is not the highest calling, and a life can be wholly meaningful without it.

Source: On the Good of Marriage

Immanuel Kant

1724–1804 · Germany

Kantian ethics

Kant argued that parents owe duties to the children they bring into the world, because creating a person without consent imposes obligations of care. He saw procreation as an act carrying heavy moral responsibility rather than a mere preference.

Bringing a person into existence binds you to look after their welfare and development, so the decision must be made with a sober sense of that obligation.

Source: The Metaphysics of Morals

Arthur Schopenhauer

1788–1860 · Germany

Pessimism

Schopenhauer held that life is dominated by striving and suffering, driven by a blind will that uses sexual desire to perpetuate itself. On this view, procreation serves the species' will rather than the individual's happiness.

The urge to have children is nature's trick to keep the cycle of striving going, so one should question whether it serves one's own good or only the will to live.

Source: The World as Will and Representation

Ask your own

0 / 300