Mind · Philosophy of mind

What is the self?

The thinkers split between those who affirm a real self (as soul, Atman, thinking substance or God-oriented inner life) and those who dissolve it into bundles, processes or models (Buddha, Hume, Parfit, Metzinger). In between, Locke and Kant ground the self in the continuity or unity of consciousness, while Kierkegaard and Beauvoir see it as something one becomes through relation and choice.

12 perspectivesClaude Sonnet 5.5Updated Oct 27, 2026A fresh run is rate limited and uses the same request limits as the rest of Perspective.

Answerability

No right answer

15 / 100

NoneContestedFactual

Common ground

Where they agree

Fault lines

Where they differ

  • Whether a real, enduring self exists: Plato, Shankara, Augustine and Descartes affirm one (soul, Atman, thinking substance), while Buddha, Hume, Parfit and Metzinger deny it or reduce it to processes.
  • The nature of the real self: Plato and Descartes see a distinct rational or thinking substance, Shankara sees one undivided awareness identical with Brahman, and Locke defines it by memory and consciousness rather than substance.
  • Whether the self is given or made: Plato, Shankara and Descartes treat it as already there to be recognized, while Kierkegaard and Beauvoir treat it as a task or project achieved through choice.
  • The role of society and situation: Beauvoir stresses social conditions and imposed definitions, whereas Descartes, Hume and Kant focus mainly on the individual mind.
  • Kant treats the self as the formal unifying condition of experience, unlike Hume's bundle, which has no real unifier beyond imagination, and unlike Metzinger's model, which is a constructed representation.
  • The practical upshot differs: Buddha and Parfit suggest that seeing through the self eases suffering or fear, Shankara promises liberation through realizing identity with Brahman, and Augustine and Kierkegaard locate fulfillment in relation to God.
  • Method: Descartes and Augustine rely on introspective certainty, Hume uses introspection to find no self, Parfit uses thought experiments, and Metzinger draws on cognitive science.

The council

12 perspectives

Plato

c. 428–348 BCE · Greece

Platonism

Plato identifies the self with the rational soul, which is distinct from the body and akin to the eternal Forms. Self-knowledge means turning the soul toward truth and ordering its parts under reason.

The true person is the immortal, reasoning soul, which the body merely houses and often distracts from knowing what is real.

Source: Phaedo

Buddhism

The Buddhist teaching of anatta denies a permanent, unchanging self. What we call a self is a shifting collection of aggregates: form, feeling, perception, mental formations and consciousness.

There is no fixed core behind experience; clinging to a lasting self is the root of suffering, and seeing its absence brings freedom.

Advaita Vedanta

Shankara taught that the true self, Atman, is pure consciousness and is identical with Brahman, the ultimate reality. The individual ego is a product of ignorance that superimposes limits on this unlimited awareness.

Beneath the personality lies one undivided awareness, and realizing that it is the same as ultimate reality dissolves the sense of separate selfhood.

Source: Upadesasahasri

Augustine of Hippo

North Africa

Christian Platonism

Augustine turns inward, finding the self in memory, understanding and will, and as a restless mystery to itself. The self is made in God's image and finds rest only in God.

I am a puzzle to myself, a deep inner space of memory and desire that is only fulfilled when oriented toward God.

Source: Confessions

René Descartes

1596–1650 · France

Rationalism

Descartes grounds the self in the certainty of thinking: doubting everything, he still cannot doubt that he is a thinking thing. The self is an immaterial mind distinct from the body.

The one thing I cannot coherently doubt is that I am thinking, so the self is first of all a thinking substance.

Source: Meditations on First Philosophy

John Locke

England

Empiricism

Locke defines personal identity by continuity of consciousness and memory rather than by substance. A person is a thinking being who can recognize itself as the same across time, which matters for responsibility.

I am the same self as far as my consciousness reaches back to earlier thoughts and deeds, whatever the underlying substance may be.

Source: An Essay Concerning Human Understanding

Ask your own

0 / 300