Religion · Meaning

Why is there suffering?

These thinkers split between those who explain suffering as arising from desire, judgment, or ignorance (Buddha, Nagarjuna, Epicurus, Epictetus, Zhuangzi, Schopenhauer) and those who place it within a moral or divine order (Augustine, Leibniz, Hick). Nietzsche, Frankl, and Weil shift the focus from why suffering exists to how it can be given meaning or met with attention, though Weil distrusts any explanation that softens its reality.

12 perspectivesClaude Sonnet 5.5Updated Oct 27, 2026A fresh run is rate limited and uses the same request limits as the rest of Perspective.

Answerability

No right answer

20 / 100

NoneContestedFactual

Fault lines

Where they differ

  • Origin: Augustine blames the fall and the misuse of free will, Leibniz points to the structure of the best possible world, Schopenhauer to a blind cosmic will, and Epicurus to the natural conditions of embodied life with no divine purpose.
  • Whether suffering has a justifying purpose: Leibniz and Hick say it serves a greater good, while Schopenhauer sees no redeeming purpose and Weil warns that explaining it away betrays the afflicted.
  • Remedy: the Buddhists and Epicurus aim at ending or minimizing suffering, the Stoics at mastering judgment, Nietzsche at affirming suffering as a source of strength, and Weil at attentive compassion.
  • Value of desire and life: Schopenhauer and the Buddha treat craving as the root problem to be renounced, whereas Nietzsche celebrates striving and sees denial of life as a sickness.
  • Self and reality: Nagarjuna and Zhuangzi dissolve fixed categories of self and good and bad, while Augustine, Epictetus, and Hick keep a stable moral order and responsible agents.
  • Theodicy: Augustine, Leibniz, and Hick try to reconcile suffering with God, whereas Epicurus rejects divine involvement and Nietzsche suspects religious explanations of devaluing life.

The council

12 perspectives

Buddhism

The Buddha taught that suffering (dukkha) is a basic feature of conditioned existence. He traced it to craving and ignorance, and proposed a practical path to its cessation.

Suffering arises because we cling to impermanent things as if they could last; when craving and ignorance are released, suffering can end.

Source: Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta

Augustine of Hippo

North Africa

Christian theology

Augustine argued that God created a good world and that evil is not a substance but a privation of good. Suffering follows from the misuse of free will and the fall of humanity.

Evil is a lack of good rather than a thing in itself, and suffering enters the world through the turning of free creatures away from God.

Source: Confessions

Epicurus

341–270 BCE · Greece

Epicureanism

Epicurus saw suffering as a natural part of embodied life, not a divine punishment. He sought to reduce it by limiting desires and removing groundless fears, especially of gods and death.

Much of our suffering comes from needless fears and excessive desires, and a simple life with friends can lessen it considerably.

Source: Letter to Menoeceus

Epictetus

Roman Empire

Stoicism

Epictetus held that distress comes less from events than from our judgments about them. He urged distinguishing what is in our control from what is not.

We suffer chiefly because we value things beyond our control; correct our judgments and much of the pain loses its hold.

Source: Enchiridion

Arthur Schopenhauer

1788–1860 · Europe

German pessimism

Schopenhauer saw the world as driven by a blind, insatiable will. Constant striving and dissatisfaction make suffering the basic condition of life, relieved only by art, compassion, and ascetic denial.

Because existence is driven by endless wanting that can never be fully satisfied, suffering is built into life itself.

Source: The World as Will and Representation

Rationalist theodicy

Leibniz coined the term theodicy for justifying God given evil. He argued that God chose the best possible world, in which some evils are necessary conditions of a greater overall good.

Among all possible worlds this one has the best balance of goods, and the suffering in it is part of what makes that whole best.

Source: Theodicy

Ask your own

0 / 300